What recent tax cases teach us about planning
Cases are stories about what went wrong or right, and many repeat the same lessons: dates are strict, records matter and the role you actually play can count more than a label.
Prepared by Prem Tax and Accounting Corp. Last reviewed November 6, 2026. Figures as of November 6, 2026.
Cases are stories about what went wrong or right, and many repeat the same few lessons. Dates are strict, paper trails matter and the role you actually play in a business can count more than the label on it. We turn them into habits with the Deadline-Folder Lesson Loop. The full list of decisions is on our recent decisions page.
- Four circuits ruled in 2025 and 2026 on the 90-day deadline to petition the Tax Court. Three allowed late filing to be excused in principle. One did not.
- A partner's real role in running a business can matter for self-employment tax.
- The non-willful FBAR penalty maximum is counted per report, not per account.
| Lesson | From these cases | What people in this situation often do |
|---|---|---|
| Treat court deadlines as firm | Buller (Second Circuit, 2025), Oquendo (Sixth, 2025) and Maniktala (Eighth, 2026) allowed tolling. Kyick (First, August 17, 2026) did not and upheld dismissal. | Calendar the deadline the day a notice arrives and file early. Tolling, where it exists, needs diligence and an extraordinary circumstance. |
| Your role can outweigh your label | K Alain, No. 24-60240 (Fifth Circuit, August 12, 2026): for self-employment tax, a limited partner is one with no significant role in managing the business. | Write down who runs what, and ask us how your agreement and your actual duties fit. |
| Foreign account reports count by report | Bittner (Supreme Court, 2023): the $10,000 non-willful maximum applies per report. | List every foreign account each year and file the report on time. Willful penalties are separate. |
| Collection fights have a limit | Zuch (Supreme Court, 2025): the Tax Court case ends once the IRS drops the levy. | Ask about a refund claim as its own step. |
An invented example
Dev did not file his report of foreign bank accounts (FBAR) for 3 years. He had 8 foreign accounts each year, and the failure was not willful. A per-account count, which the Supreme Court rejected in Bittner, would be 3 times 8 times $10,000, or $240,000. Under its per-report rule, the most is 3 times $10,000, or $30,000. We use the $10,000 figure the Court applied. Check the current amount, because penalty figures can be adjusted.
The Deadline-Folder Lesson Loop
- Start a folder the day any IRS or court letter arrives, with the date and the deadline on top.
- Keep proof of every filing: mail receipts, delivery tracking and e-file confirmations.
- Keep a list of foreign accounts and a note of who does what in the business.
- Reread the folder at the end of each year and ask your adviser what has changed.
- Use tracking tax changes to follow new rulings.
Common questions
Can I get extra time if I miss a Tax Court deadline?
It depends on the statute and the circuit. The Second, Sixth and Eighth Circuits allowed tolling for the 90-day deficiency deadline in 2025 and 2026 rulings. The First did not. The Tax Court still treats that deadline as jurisdictional in circuits that have not ruled. We found no Seventh Circuit ruling on it, so we treat the deadline as firm.
Does a case about a big company apply to me?
Only if the same rule and court reach you. Read [how to read tax cases](/current-topics/cases/how-to-read-tax-cases/) first.
Which K Alain opinion should I read?
The one filed August 12, 2026. A January 2026 opinion in that case was withdrawn, and the case was formerly captioned Sirius Solutions. Cite it by docket number.
Official sources
- First Circuit: Kyick Holdings v. Commissioner, opinion
- Eighth Circuit: Maniktala v. Commissioner, opinion
- Second Circuit: Buller v. Commissioner, opinion
- Sixth Circuit: Oquendo v. Commissioner, opinion
- Fifth Circuit: K Alain L.L.L.P. v. Commissioner, opinion
- Supreme Court: Bittner v. United States, opinion
- Supreme Court: Commissioner v. Zuch, opinion
Keep reading
- Recent tax cases and rulings, in plain English
- How to read a tax case or IRS ruling: who it binds and how much it weighs
- Recent tax decisions and rulings that matter most to families and owners
- Where the new tax law leaves gaps: Illinois, other states and the IRS
- How we follow tax changes, and how you can too
Let's talk about your taxes, your business, your plans.
Tell us what you need and we will get back to you quickly. There is no pressure: just a friendly conversation and a clear next step.
4260 Westbrook Dr, Suite 107
Aurora, IL 60504